Claims checked

45 verdicts
18%higher colorectal cancer risk per 50 g of processed meat a dayMOSTLYSupported

Is Red Meat Bad For You? Processed Meat Is The Real Answer

Two cartoon rashers of bacon, beside the figure 18 percent

Processed meat carries an 18% higher colorectal cancer risk per 50 g a day — and two reviews covering four and six million people concluded the absolute effects are 'very small' with low-certainty evidence. Both are true. Here is why, what IARC's Group 1 actually means, and why steak is a different question.

75glycaemic index of instant oatmeal — granola is 56MOSTLYSupported

Is Oatmeal Good For Weight Loss? A Little. But Instant Oats Score Worse Than Granola.

A cartoon bowl of porridge with a spoon, beside the figure 75

Pooled across 72 measurements, instant oatmeal scored 75 on the glycaemic index and granola scored 56 — the breakfast with the health halo performs worse than the one people feel guilty about. The real, regulator-approved oat claim is about cholesterol, at 3 g of beta-glucan a day, and it saturates there.

0.81risk of death at the highest intake, versus noneMOSTLYSupported

Is Olive Oil Good For You? Yes — But Not Compared To The Oils You’ve Been Told To Fear

A cartoon olive sprig with leaves and three olives, beside the figure 0.81

The famous PREDIMED trial was retracted from the New England Journal of Medicine and republished — and the nuts arm did just as well as the olive oil arm. Across 92,000 people over 28 years, olive oil beat butter and margarine handily. Against other vegetable oils, no significant difference at all.

6.13mg/dL further LDL drop than olive oilNOUnsupported

Is Canola Oil Bad For You? The Thing It’s Accused Of Was Bred Out Fifty Years Ago

A cartoon four-petalled canola flower on a stem, beside the figure 6.13

Canola is rapeseed bred low in erucic acid — the name literally means Canadian oil, low acid. The FDA ban people cite was against mustard oil, not this. Even in the rat studies the heart lesions were judged 'not related to erucic acid per se'. And in 13 head-to-head trials, canola lowered LDL more than olive oil did.

90%cut from the diet — arachidonic acid didn't moveNOUnsupported

Are Seed Oils Bad For You? Both Sides Are Quoting Half The Evidence

A cartoon bottle of cooking oil, part filled, beside the figure 90 percent

Cut dietary linoleic acid by 90% and tissue arachidonic acid doesn't move — the inflammation mechanism fails at step one. But the two recovered BMJ trials showed no mortality benefit and one showed higher deaths, which the reassurance articles never mention. Here is the whole file, including what's wrong with both halves.

60-80%of your creatine tank is already fullYESEstablished

How Much Creatine Should You Take? 3 To 5 Grams — And You’re Already Most Of The Way There

A cartoon measuring scoop heaped with powder, beside the figure 60 to 80 percent

On an ordinary diet your muscle creatine is already 60–80% saturated, and supplementing fills the rest. Which is why one biopsy study found a six-fold difference in response to the identical dose — the people who gained most started with the most room. Loading only changes how fast you arrive.

0laxative effect from 40 g of maltitolMOSTLYSupported

Are Sugar Alcohols Bad For You? The Real Problem Is Digestive

Four cartoon chocolate bars, the last one snapped short, beside the figure zero

Same trial, same 59 people, same 40-gram dose: lactitol caused severe symptoms across the board and maltitol caused no laxative effect at all. Both are labelled sugar alcohols. Europe's regulator set a limit on erythritol for diarrhoea — not clots — and refused to drop the warning label. And the erythritol and xylitol heart scares came from one dataset.