The 2023 study linking erythritol to heart attacks came with a real mechanism — more reactive platelets, more clotting in animals. But the cohorts measured erythritol in blood, not diet, and your body makes its own: plasma levels track metabolic disease and fall after weight loss. Marker or cause is genuinely unresolved.
On the same day in July 2023, IARC called aspartame 'possibly carcinogenic' — a hazard statement, third of four levels — and JECFA reaffirmed the safe daily intake, noting a 70 kg adult would need 9–14 cans of diet drink a day to exceed it. The press ran the first report. WHO's own nutrition director said safety is not a major concern at normal doses.
Swapping sugary drinks for diet ones took off 2.3 lb across 17 randomised trials, and swapping for water did nothing. But the Framingham study found daily cola drinkers had 3.7% lower hip bone density — and diet cola looked the same, so switching does not buy you out of that one.
The WHO guideline covers 'all synthetic and naturally occurring' sweeteners and names stevia in the same list as aspartame — natural is written out as an exemption on purpose. And stevia has about a third the randomised trial evidence of aspartame, so the confidence people feel about it is not coming from a deeper evidence base.
The 2023 study behind 'sweetener damages DNA' is real, competently run and industry-free — and every experiment in it happened in a dish. Its own authors write that the health effects 'are not yet known'. That sentence did not make the coverage.
The WHO advises against non-sugar sweeteners — as a conditional recommendation, on evidence it grades low certainty, from a harm signal that is observational, in a document that names reverse causation itself. Meanwhile 17 randomised trials found swapping sugary drinks for sweetened ones took off 2.3 lb, while swapping for water did nothing.
Canning doesn't destroy the omega-3s — canned pink salmon carries more than a gram per 100 g. But albacore packed in oil holds 0.24 g against 0.86 g for the same fish in water, because the fat dissolves into the oil and the oil goes down the sink. Figures pulled from USDA FoodData Central, with the FDA/EPA mercury lists alongside.
Nineteen people ate 441 calories a day less without being told to, purely from moving protein from 15% to 30% of their meals — with the appetite hormones pushing the other way. But when 38 foods were ranked head to head, the most filling was a boiled potato, and water content predicted fullness better than protein did.
Soluble fibre supplements produced about 2.8 lb more weight loss on average across 22 trials — an average, not a prediction for any one person, and most of those trials paired fibre with a calorie-restricted diet. The Lancet's 25–29 g/day target comes from a review that excluded supplement trials entirely.
13 trials, 606 people, and a real dose-response — but an I-squared of 94%, meaning the trials flatly disagree, and no figure you could act on. Meanwhile the famous green coffee claim of 17.7 lb 'with or without diet and exercise' came from a study whose weights were altered. It cost $3.5 million and was retracted.