Claims checked

32 verdicts
39stevia trials, against aspartame's 121MAYBEPreliminary

Is Stevia Bad For You? “Natural” Is Not a Safety Category

Cartoon serrated stevia leaf on a stem, beside the figure 39

The WHO guideline covers 'all synthetic and naturally occurring' sweeteners and names stevia in the same list as aspartame — natural is written out as an exemption on purpose. And stevia has about a third the randomised trial evidence of aspartame, so the confidence people feel about it is not coming from a deeper evidence base.

2.3 lblost swapping sugar for sweetenerMAYBEPreliminary

Are Artificial Sweeteners Bad For You? The WHO Hedged — Here’s Why

Cartoon sweetener sachet torn open at the top with grains spilling out, beside the figure 2.3 pounds

The WHO advises against non-sugar sweeteners — as a conditional recommendation, on evidence it grades low certainty, from a harm signal that is observational, in a document that names reverse causation itself. Meanwhile 17 randomised trials found swapping sugary drinks for sweetened ones took off 2.3 lb, while swapping for water did nothing.

72%of the omega-3 lost, packed in oilYESEstablished

Is Canned Tuna Healthy? Yes — But You’re Probably Draining the Best Part

Cartoon fish tin with the lid rolled back and drops falling from it, beside the figure 72 percent

Canning doesn't destroy the omega-3s — canned pink salmon carries more than a gram per 100 g. But albacore packed in oil holds 0.24 g against 0.86 g for the same fish in water, because the fat dissolves into the oil and the oil goes down the sink. Figures pulled from USDA FoodData Central, with the FDA/EPA mercury lists alongside.

441calories a day, eaten without noticingMOSTLYSupported

Does Protein Keep You Full? Yes — But a Potato Beat Everything

Cartoon boiled potato with steam rising, beside the figure 441

Nineteen people ate 441 calories a day less without being told to, purely from moving protein from 15% to 30% of their meals — with the appetite hormones pushing the other way. But when 38 foods were ranked head to head, the most filling was a boiled potato, and water content predicted fullness better than protein did.

94%of the disagreement is real, not chanceMAYBEPreliminary

Does Coffee Help You Lose Weight? A Little — Nobody Knows How Much

Cartoon green coffee bean with its crease down the middle, beside the figure 94 percent

13 trials, 606 people, and a real dose-response — but an I-squared of 94%, meaning the trials flatly disagree, and no figure you could act on. Meanwhile the famous green coffee claim of 17.7 lb 'with or without diet and exercise' came from a study whose weights were altered. It cost $3.5 million and was retracted.